Jun 26, 2007 vote against banner shows divide on speech in schools. The court said the phrase bong hits 4 jesus reasonably could be viewed as. June 25, 2007 background joseph frederick, a senior at juneaudouglas high school, held up a banner saying. Students free speech rights go up in smoke huffpost. He said it can hardly be argued that either students or teachers shed their constitutional rights to freedom of speech or expression at the schoolhouse gate. Life could bong hits 4 jesus case chill free speech in schools. Ultimate court case study set 1 flashcards quizlet. However, with the bong hits 4 jesus sign the court ruled in fact that the kids were disturbing the school day. B based on the similarity identified in part a explain why. He and others displayed a banner with the message bong hits 4 jesus. Bong hits 4 jesus and the first amendment teen ink. Justices will hear a case involving a student from alaska, who is. Des moines independent community school district and morse v. In upholding the 10day suspension of an alaska high school senior for raising a banner that read bong hits 4 jesus at a schoolsanctioned event outside campus, the court majority insisted it.
However in 2002, principal deborah morse violated the first amendment, when she tore down a banner reading bong hits 4 jesus. Hazelwood and bong hits 4 jesus the supreme court has affirmed the right of schools to restrict student speech in schoolsponsored activities in two key cases over the last three decades. The school officials ability to limit student first. Jul 26, 2017 the court has sometimes gone wrong on free speech. Frederick, in which the supreme court held that a school principal did not violate the constitution by punishing a student for unfurling a banner reading, bong hits 4 jesus.
Introduction in 1969, the supreme court observed that students do not shed their constitutional rights to freedom of speech or expression at the schoolhousegate. Frederick, the supreme court case that addressed free speech in an american high school. The first amendment protects free speech, but some types of speech are given greater protection than others. To the extent the court independently finds that bong hits 4 jesus objectively amounts to the advocacy of illegal drug usein other words, that it can most reasonably be interpreted as suchthat conclusion practically refutes itself. The article advocates the necessity of making sure students understand the points and implications of the first amendment by providing a mock trial unit concerning free speech rights. As such, the state had an important if not compelling interest in prohibitingpunishing such student speech. How it came to the conclusion, however, was by analyzing the incredibly technical language thusly note all of the language. Bong hits 4 jesus as a cautionary tale of two cities. Mar 19, 2007 a high school seniors 14foot banner proclaiming bong hits 4 jesus gave the supreme court a provocative prop for a lively argument monday about the extent of schools control over.
Freedom of speech, freedom of the press, right to bear arms freedom of religion, speech. He and some friends waited for the television cameras to pass by and then unfurled a large banner reading bong hits 4 jesus. What would harry potter say about bong hits 4 jesus. They will be responsible for reading information related to the bong hits for jesus case. Supreme court allows foul language trademarks in fword. Justices hear bong hits freespeech case the supreme court reexamines the rights of students to exercise free speech in school.
Double standards on free speech minding the campus. High court upholds students suspension for bong hits 4. Frederick sued, claiming his constitutional rights to free speech were violated. Supreme court considers whether a highschool principal in alaska should have suspended a student for displaying a banner that read. The student who had unfurled the banner, joseph frederick, sued. Students will be placed into four groups of nine students apiece. If you want to a get on national television with a stunt, b have a message guaranteed to annoy people, and most importantly, c really enrage your schools principal then youve got to word the message carefully. At a schoolsanctioned and schoolsupervised event, petitioner morse, the high school principal, saw students unfurl a banner stating bong hits 4 jesus, which she regarded as promoting illegal drug use. Determining that it could discern no meaningful distinction between student newspaper stories that were deleted. The bbc reports on the supreme court ruling that a school in alaska did not violate joseph fredericks right to free speech when it suspended him for displaying a banner reading bong hits 4 jesus. And the rub is that school principals have very broad latitude to determine if it does. Courts have accepted tighter limits on fighting words, dangerous speech, and obscenity. In our view, students not only do not shed their constitutional rights to freedom of speech or expression at the schoolhouse gate, as the court held in tinker v. The school went outside to watch the the olympic torch when the kids revealed the sign bong hits 4 jesus.
Courts have granted political speech the greatest protection under the first amendment. To the extent the court independently finds that bong hits 4 jesus objectively amounts to the advocacy of illegal drug use in other words, that it can most reasonably be interpreted as such that conclusion practically refutes. We made a large banner that said free speech 4 students and we had students holding up posters saying the same thing. Professor james foster talks about his book, bong hits 4 jesus, in which he discusses morse v.
Frederick denies that his bong hits 4 jesus banner was intended to promote drug use. They have performed alongside numerous acts including sublime w rome, cypress hill, pepper, slightly stoopid, and have. Supreme court will take up carries potentially farreaching consequences for student speech, and for the legal protections of public school educators. Bong hits 4 jesus, which she regarded as promoting illegal. It found that frederick message was, by his own admission, not political, as was the case in tinker. Supreme court hears bong hits 4 jesus politics nbc news. We were trying to move the focus from the silly bong hits banner to this being a free speech issue, said ssdps krane. This article provides some strategies to alleviate the current tensions between personal responsibility and freedom of speech rights in the public school classroom.
Consistent with established school policy prohibiting such messages at school events, morse directed the students to take down the banner. Frederick, better known as the bong hits 4 jesus case. Taking its eyebrowraising name from a supreme court free speech case, the band stands for freedom of speech, selfexpression, legalization, and having fun. Jun 25, 2007 student loses bong hits 4 jesus case june 25, 2007 10. Frederick on january 23, 2002, students and staff at juneaudouglas high school went to a public event where the olympic torch passed by. The school officials ability to limit student first amendment freedom. Mar 05, 2011 washington cnn the supreme court ruled against a former high school student monday in the bong hits 4 jesus banner case a split decision that limits students free speech rights. In his view, he was making a statement about free speech itself. In 2002, then high school senior joseph frederick unfurled a 14foot banner reading bong hits 4 jesus during a school field trip to watch the olympic torch pass through juneau, alaska. The schools principal, deborah morse, ordered the students to drop the banner, but frederick did not comply and was suspended.
Bong hits for jesus bong hits for jesus is equal parts rock, funk, reggae, hip hop, and punk. Soon after the cameras caught the act, his high school principal suspended him for ten days for displaying the banner, in apparent violation of school policy limiting speech that promotes illegal drug use. In 2007, the united states supreme court issued its opinion in the closely watched case of morse v. Professor james foster talks about his book, bong hits 4 jesus. Those words are used over and over in other supreme court cases further down the line. Frederick, the supreme court case that addressed free speech in an. The reason most academic articles are not similarly. Phd doctor of philosophy thesis, university of iowa, 2009. Bong hits 4 jesus during the olympic torch relay through juneau, alaska on january 24, 2002. Fredericks, aka bong hits 4 jesus, is a first amendment freespeech case. Mar 19, 2007 the supreme court monday debated the case of a high school principal who suspended a student over a bong hits 4 jesus, banner displayed at a schoolsponsored event. Without free speech, we would not be able to assemble in groups to publically debate and challenge government policies or laws. Roberts wrote another opinion upholding the silencing of a highschool student who unfurled a banner reading bong hits 4 jesus.
So remember, dont say bong hits 4 jesus, say instead. Dupre examines the history of the debate on free speech in schools in the contexts of protests, student publications, religious speech, textbook selection, teacher speech, and civility. Student loses bong hits free speech case, 2007 newseumed. Joe unrolled a 14foot banner bearing the words bong hits 4 jesus.
The eu is austrias coconspirator in this attack on freedom of speech. Established precedent of federalizing bill of rights applying them to states. The article develops its argument by focusing in general on the school speech cases and in particular on the recent decision of morse v. However, with the rise in gang violence, drugs, and alcohol, the supreme court has shifted its sympathetic view towards schools more so than the student. Could bong hits 4 jesus case chill free speech in schools. A conversation on the constitution with justices stephen. Federal court upholds college punishment for offcampus facebook posts said to violate vague standards a decision like this opens the door, free speech advocate warns. But i still had enough time left over to write articles that contributed insights to the scholarly community. Schools can limit a students right to freedom of speech. Topic selection chart fill in the chart before you contact your teacher to schedule your discussionbased assessment for this lesson. Frederick morse 2007, the supreme court relied on all three of its previous cases in concluding that a principal could limit student expressive speech at a school activity when a student unfurled a 14 foot banner that proclaimed bong hits 4 jesus. Emma sullivan and the big brownback backdown the atlantic.
Thats, you know, materially disruptive to the educational enterprise. In the morse case, a student held up a sign that said bong hits 4 jesus at a schoolsupervised parade and was. The high court decision in the bong hits case morse v. Jun 25, 2007 the supreme court ruled against a former high school student monday in the bong hits 4 jesus banner case a split decision that limits students free speech rights. Vote against banner shows divide on speech in schools the. Frederick and the democratic implications of using in loco parentis to subordinate tinker and curtail student speech andrea kayne kaufman juris doctorate 1993 university of pennsylvania law school, masters of education 1990 harvard unive rsity graduate school of education. At a schoolsupervised event, joseph frederick held up a banner with the message bong hits 4 jesus, a slang reference to marijuana smoking. To the extent that the media focused on us, we succeeded better than we had ever imagined. In 2002, juneaudouglas high school principal deborah morse suspended joseph frederick after he displayed a banner reading bong hits 4 jesus across the street from the school during the 2002 winter olympics torch relay. Speech the issue of freedom of speech has very often been misunderstood and misinterpreted by american citizens who believe they can say anything they want. In what is being called a landmark decision, the u. Justices discuss students free speech rights in the supreme court cases tinker v. Free speech helps us to enact other freedoms protected by the first amendment, including freedom of assembly and freedom of religion. Finding that the message frederick displayed was by his own admission not political in nature, as was the case in tinker, the court said the phrase bong hits 4 jesus reasonably could be viewed as promoting illegal drug use.
Bong hits 4 jesus considers whether this recalibration of student speech rights is a major retreat. Federal court upholds college punishment for offcampus. Frederick sued, saying it was offcampus speech and not disruptive to the school. Mar 19, 2007 justices hear bong hits freespeech case the supreme court reexamines the rights of students to exercise free speech in school. States cannot deny freedom of speech protected through due process clause of amendment 14. Download 4page term paper on freedom of speech morse v. In morse, the supreme court found that a public high school had not violated the first amendment rights of a student suspended for unfurling a banner reading bong hits 4 jesus at a schoolsponsored, offcampus event. It upheld a public high schools suspension of a student who brandished a sign saying bong hits 4 jesus, which it took to be a prodrug. Using the url or doi link below will ensure access to this page indefinitely. Principal deborah morse took away the banner and suspended frederick for ten days. Background information on the 2007 supreme court case known as the bong hits 4 jesus case. Terrifying teen speech in the news again the atlantic. After he unfurled his 14foot bong hits 4 jesus banner on a. Sep 16, 20 a large bong hits 4 jesus banner, which led to a 2007 supreme court decision that said such language was not protected free speech under the first amendment when displayed at a public school event, is now on prominent display at the newseum in washington, d.
The bbc reports on the supreme court ruling that a school in alaska did not violate joseph fredericks right to free speech when it suspended him for displaying a. When will the european union order twitter to silence. Bong hits 4 jesus is one of the more entertaining one, and a good example of how. Frederick was interested in more than just watching the relay. The court said the phrase bong hits 4 jesus reasonably could be viewed as promoting illegal drug use. From a sea of controversies over student speechon tshirts, in classroom. Today the supreme court found that the phrase bong hits 4 jesus meant advocating or promoting the use of illegal drugs. Mar 19, 2007 supreme court weighs student free speech case on monday, u. Download it once and read it on your kindle device, pc, phones or tablets.
Frederick was another limitation on a landmark 1969 student speech decision, tinker v. This first amendment case was closely watched by public school administrators because the ninth circuit court of appeals had earlier overruled a lower courts finding that no first amendment violation had occurred and instead ruled. Students dont leave their right to free speech at the school door, the high court said in a vietnamera case over an antiwar protest by high school students. Bong hits 4 jesus and millions of other books are available for amazon kindle. School authorities do not violate the first amendment when they stop students. The student who held the banner sued the school in morse v fredrick see bong hits. She also includes as a case study the alaska case of the students who sued when suspended for displaying a bong hits 4 jesus banner.
She justified her actions by citing the schools policy against the display of material that promotes the use of illegal. That decision declared that students do not shed their constitutional right to freedom of speech or expression at the schoolhouse gate. The original bong hits 4 jesus banner now hangs in the first amendment gallery of the. Fredericks attendance at the event was part of a schoolsupervised activity. Although he never made it to school that day because he got stuck in the snow, he joined his classmates on a public sidewalk across the street from school. This first amendment case was closely watched by public school administrators because the ninth circuit court of appeals had earlier overruled a lower courts finding that no first amendment violation had occurred and. Aug 24, 2012 terrifying teen speech in the news again. Mar 20, 2007 bong hits for jesus do students have free speech. Jun 25, 2007 the ruling reads like nothing so much as a goofy tv ad denouncing pot, but in the end, roberts gets it about right when he says the case of the kid suspended for unfurling a bong hits 4 jesus banner across from school hardly justifies sounding the first amendment bugle. The phrase bong hits 4 jesus came to life as a 15foot banner.
The precipitious slide in supreme court protection for free speech in high school since tinker. A perfect constitutional storm in alaskas capital foster, james c. Despite the lessthanweighty incident at its corethe display of a homemade banner emblazoned with bong hits 4 jesusa case that the u. B based on the similarity identified in part a, explain why the facts of the morse v. Why did baraboo district decide not to punish nazisalute. Get your kindle here, or download a free kindle reading app. But chief justice john roberts, in an opinion for the court, parsed the statement with all the delicate irony of a hal9000 to conclude.
1608 1611 1428 1215 156 491 1291 72 870 1037 183 1271 1376 1299 678 770 1341 1235 539 1332 1578 1409 1534 642 465 1461 1319 1344 1280 713 1307 766